a new take on the transparent society: solving the problem of externalities with the byproducts of information-enabling everything: supply chains, health care, sensor networks, etc
Tag: usergeneratedcontent
Media Radical Transparency
Here are some thoughts on what a truly transparent media organization would do.
- Show who we are
Upside: Readers know who to contact. The organization is revealed as a collection of diverse individuals, not just a brand, an editor and some writers.
Risk: Competitors know who to poach; PR people spam us even more than usual.
- Show what we’re working on
Upside: Tap the wisdom of crowds
Risk: Tip off competitors(although I’d argue that this would just as likely freeze them; after all the prior art would be obvious to all); Risks “scooping ourselves”,robbing the final product of freshness.
- “Process as Content”
Upside: Open participation can make stories better–better researched, better thought through and deeper. It also can crowdsource some of the work of the copy desk and editors. And once the story is done and published, the participants have a sense of collective ownership that encourages them to spread the word.
Risk:Curating the process can quickly hit diminishing returns. Writers end up feeling like a cruise director, constantly trying to get people to participate. And all the other risks of the item above.
- Privilege the crowd
Upside: Maximizes participation.
Risk: If we don’t deploy voting tools or (sigh) a login system, trolls may rule.
- Let readers decide what’s best
Upside: A front page that reflects reader interest better.
Risk: A more predictable and lowbrow front page.
- Wikify everything
Upside: Stories live and grow, remaining relevant long after their original publication (at no cost to us!)
Risk: Stories get progressively less coherent as many cooks mess with them. Whatever brand authority the Wired name brings is diminished over time as the stories become less and less our own work.
EPIC 2014
EPIC is so popular that it triggers the downfall of the New York Times, which goes offline and becomes “a print newsletter for the elite and the elderly.
Map Quest
teleatlas tries to find new roads from google news alerts, navteq drives around
Each discovery Williams makes – 30-40 per week – soon ends up on a map of the country. That information will then become accessible to computers, GPS devices, and, one hopes, the car navigation system used by the UPS delivery guy in Indiana. But Tele Atlas has decided to plot the world by starting with the electronic news alert instead of the steering wheel. The cartographic competition has suddenly become intense.
has last.fm jumped the shark?
last.fm used to give me great recommendations, now it gives me nirvana and 9 inch nails when i ask for bands similar to air. looks like the site is being overrun by people with horrible music tastes, alas.
User-generated accuracy
Now that GoYellow Maps has been live for a couple days, I find it interesting that the most common reaction is to note that the map data is out of date in some places, by between 1 and 4 years. We are not alone with this: map.search.ch pretty much saw the same phenomenon, and Google Maps encounters it too.
I am wondering if this is a trick that perception plays on us: If we see an image of sufficiently high quality, our disbelief is suspended, and we assume immediacy. Case in point, when my dad first saw the nice bird’s eye pictures from MSN local, he immediately asked why the cars in the picture are not moving. While we wait for the advent of real time satellite data, the lesson seems to be that the additional precision and detail of hybrid maps make any problems with accuracy more obvious. Overall, I think it is a fair trade-off given that these hybrid maps fascinate people enough to seek out these inaccuracies. I mean, when is the last time you heard someone get excited about inaccuracies in a telephone book?
It might be possible, given easy to use tools, to harness this deep local knowledge people have about their immediate surroundings. At which point you’d have yet another industry hopping onto the user-generated content bandwagon.
Second life euphemism
Second life is an euphemism for a busy retirement
Though it is widely understood that broadband technologies that allow rapid and ‘always on’ connections to the Internet will provide significant benefits to the US economy, this report is the first to estimate the economic benefits to the nation due to cost savings and output expansion resulting from the use of broadband technologies for an important specific sub-group of the US population: the 70m Americans who are over 65 or under that age but have disabilities. 3 types of benefits from broadband deployment and use are addressed: lower medical costs; lower costs of institutionalized living; and additional output generated by more seniors and individuals with disabilities in the labor force. Considered together, these 3 benefits are estimated to accumulate to at least $927B in cost savings and output gains in 2005 $ (with future benefits discounted for the ‘time value of money’) over the 25 year period, 2005 to 2030. This amount is equivalent to 50% of what the United States currently spends annually for medical care for all its citizens ($1.8 trillion). As large as these benefits may appear, they are line with previous estimates for the benefits of broadband for the population as a whole. Policies designed to accelerate the use of broadband for these populations, however, could significantly add to the benefits, by cumulative amounts ranging from $532B to $847B (depending on the wages earned by the additional working seniors). The policy benefits are as substantial as what the federal government is likely to spend on homeland security over the next 25 years. Total cumulative benefits, under the right set of policies, could exceed what the United States currently spends annually for health care for all its citizens. Clearly, with so much at stake, policymakers have strong reasons to consider measures to accelerate the deployment and use of broadband technologies for America’s seniors and individuals with disabilities.
when you retire, your second life will be online. i had heard many a commenter mention their time constraints when faced with World of Warcraft or second life. is it unreasonable to expect a bimodal distribution on these platforms in the future? the young and the old certainly have the time. if these systems are able to attract older segments of the population, things will get interesting. actually, they already do.
if we leverage these enormous resources, ideally by making things like the mechanical turk or wikipedia fun for a large part of them, we’ll easily be able handle pensions and health care for a rapidly aging population, and still have funds left over for many more charity and nonprofit projects than today.
i always believed that a major reason for the bursting of the first bubble was that the internet experience of the average person is riddled with viruses, spyware and spam. it’s hard to overestimate how much this destroyed the trust and interest in all things internet. so maybe part of the appeal of these online worlds is there relative lack of annoyances (surely not for long..). what is needed, therefore, is a massive, probably grassroots, effort, to clean up the world’s computers and re-establish a safe browsing experience, and get these people back online. the rest will follow.
Recommendations done right
i have recently started to use last.fm more frequently, again. i have had an account there since 2003, but had forgotten about it. in the meantime, they have built out an awesome service that works really well. it was a nice surprise to see that they upgraded early adopters to their version of a pro user, for free. this allows me to have my own radio station without lifting a finger, and other nice benefits.
coupled with their sane data policy, this is a clear winner. really useful and relevant unlike the overhyped silliness that is “podcasting”.
Intelligent design
If you’re worried sick about all the outsourcing to China, losing sleep over the wholesale shift of manufacturing jobs to the Asia-Pacific region, and constantly banging your head on the wailing wall of “free” trade please have a look at the future – emachineshop.com.
Their machines do Injection Molding, Milling, Turning, Laser Cutting, Waterjet Cutting, Wire EDM, Tapping, Bending, Blanking, Punching, Plastic Extrusion, Thermoforming, Casting with Aluminum, Steel, Stainless, Copper, Sheet metal, Brass, Bronze, Wood, Nylon, Acetal, Polycarbonate, Polystyrene, Acrylic, Plastic, Fiber Glass and many others.
Tricking slackers into working
a year ago, i wondered about the state of free knowledge creation. in the meantime, del.icio.us, flickr and foremost, wikipedia have brought infoware to a much broader audience. i have a keen interest in peer production, and i noticed recently how i am often too tired to contribute to open source projects, but end up slacking a bit and maintaining my del.icio.us account and other infoware bits instead.
this makes me wonder if infoware with it’s immediate gratification and strong network effects will have a far deeper impact on the creation of societal wealth than open source ever will. the thought that more of that almost limitless source of energy (slacking) could be tapped.