Tag: policy

FAA nonsense

Turns out the FAA, just like the TSA, is in the fear-mongering business, with just as much evidence behind their rules, ie none

The agency has no proof that electronic devices can harm a plane’s avionics, but it still perpetuates such claims, spreading irrational fear among millions of fliers.

2013-03-29: Ground regulations

Some FAA rules don’t make sense to us either. Like the fact that when we’re at 11900m going 640 km an hour, in a plane that could hit turbulence at any minute, (flight attendants) can walk around and serve hot coffee and Chateaubriand. But when we’re on the ground on a flat piece of asphalt going 16 km an hour, they’ve got to be buckled in like they’re at NASCAR.

2014-12-15: These new drones are amazing, but sadly not in the US because the FAA is confused.

Those cool nighttime drone cam shots from your local news networks? Illegal. Those YouTube hobbyist flyovers of Apple, Inc.’s (AAPL) headquarters? Illegal. Amazon.com, Inc.’s (AMZN) wild Prime Air delivery drones? Illegal. Google Inc.’s (GOOG) internet drones? Facebook Inc.’s (FB) WiFi-providing fliers? Likely illegal. Hobbyist drones, like the Da-Jiang (“Great Territory”) Innovations (DJI) Science and Technology Co., Ltd. Phantom? Likely illegal too, unless you have experience aboard a real airplane.

2015-09-02: and it is going to be a Zoo

security risks mean everyone from your city’s taxi commission to the federal Department of Transportation, will want to get involved in AV regulation. With costs likely to fall between 50% to 90%, a consumer could increase VMT by anywhere from 2X to more than 5X.

2016-09-04: Pilot grift

Drones only become truly disruptive when they don’t have pilots at all. Yet, the FAA is regulating them in a way that forces drones to have pilots.

Let me put this in terms of work. Drones without pilots make the following things possible (none of which are possible with pilots at the controls):

Tireless. Accomplish tasks 24x7x365.
Scalable. Billions of drones can be used at the same time.
Costless. The cost per minute for drone services would drop to almost nothing.
If these capabilities are unleashed, it’s possible to do for drones what the Web/Internet did for networking.

2023-05-01: Flying is still far too regulated

Contrary to the narrative that today’s airline industry is a deregulatory success story, commercial air travel remains one of the most highly regulated industries in the country. Effectively what changed after 1978 was that the federal government no longer told airlines where they’re allowed to fly, and how much they can charge. That’s no small deal. However, nearly every other element of the experience continues to be dictated—and even directly managed—by the government.

We can have a future where travel is an easier, cheaper and more pleasant experience—where we’re delayed less often and where commercial airlines genuinely compete with a host of different products so we can buy the one that suits us best instead of one size fits all. But to have this kind of abundance, we need a more open and competitive system that focuses on passengers and their needs rather than existing airlines and other special interests.

FDA nonsense

FDA commissioner Alexander M. Schmidt

In all of FDA’s history, I am unable to find a single instance where a congressional committee investigated the failure of FDA to approve a new drug. But, the times when hearings have been held to criticize our approval of new drugs have been so frequent that we aren’t able to count them. … The message to FDA staff could not be clearer.

2013-11-26: as usual, the FDA is up to no good.

At the same time that the NSA is secretly and illegally obtaining information about Americans the FDA is making it illegal for Americans to obtain information about themselves.

2014-08-05: the FDA could help by eliminating its onerous rules for diseases with 60% mortality rates. Won’t happen of course, it’s easier to bury lots of innocents than to overcome cover-your-ass (pretty much the reason for the FDA to exist). Or as the onion put it, the Ebola Vaccine is at least 50 white people away.
2016-07-15: Fluoride still not available

American dentists first started using similar silver-based treatments in the early 1900s. The FDA is literally over 100 years behind the times.It seems that the future of dental treatment has been here all along but a combination of dentists wanting to be surgeons, lost knowledge, and FDA cost and delay prevented it from being distributed

Silver diamine fluoride been used for decades in Japan, but it’s been available in the United States, under the brand name Advantage Arrest, for just ~1 year. Toddlers in low-income families sometimes have to wait 1 year for fillings in an operating room. Transporting and treating frail patients, assuming they can afford to see a dentist, can be difficult. But now some patients can be quickly treated where they live.
2020-04-17: Nutrition overregulation

1 reason why food intended for restaurants is not reallocated to supermarkets: Nutrition labeling also frequently doesn’t comply with Agriculture Department and FDA guidelines for consumer sales

2020-12-05: This is nonsense. “Delay to allay” won’t convince anyone, and meanwhile people are dying.

Dr. Fauci said the politicization of the pandemic in his own country had led regulators to move a little more cautiously than the British, to avoid losing public support. There is no plausible reason why this basic analysis cannot be done in 24 hours. The FDA and external scientists have a simple task: confirm or reject the review already conducted by the trial’s independent data safety monitoring board before FDA submission.

2021-02-07: The FDA is unable to make sense.

Think of centers of expertise like the CDC or the IGM Economists Panel as giant systems for disentangling corruption and power. Their job is to produce 1 or 2 people who can get in front of the population and say something which has some resemblance to reality, even though the entire rest of the economy and body politic is trying to corrupt them. They…actually do sort of okay. Anthony Fauci is neither Attila the Hun nor Trofim Lysenko. He’s a kind of bumbling careerist with a decent understanding of epidemiology and a heart that’s more or less in the right place. The whole scientific-technocratic complex is a machine which takes Moloch as input and manages – after spending billions of $ and the careers of 1000s of hard-working public servants – to produce Anthony Fauci as output. This should be astonishing, and we are insufficiently grateful.

2021-02-15: Why isn’t there a reciprocal approval with the EU?

I’ve long argued that if a drug or medical device is approved in another country with a Stringent Regulatory Authority it ought to be approved in the United States. But, of course, the argument is even stronger in the other direction. Drugs and devices approved in the United States ought to be approved elsewhere. Indeed, this is how much of the world actually works because most countries do not have capability to evaluate drugs and devices the way the FDA or the EMA does. Although it’s the way the world works, few will admit it because that would violate pretensions of regulatory nationalism. Moreover, keeping up with pretenses means transaction costs and unnecessary delays. Regulatory nationalism has added months to vaccine delivery and now threatens to put to waste millions of stockpiled doses.

2021-03-02: millions of people die of heart disease every year. there has been no progress in artificial hearts in 50 years due to.. wait for it.. FDA:

The FDA gave Abiomed permission to implant 60 more devices, but it was clear that the heart would need to be updated, and then approved all over again—a lengthy process for which no one had the fortitude. “Abiomed threw in the towel. They were, like, ‘This is too hard!’ ”

2021-03-16: What are FDA inspectors even doing?

Grocery store workers are working, meat packers are working, hell bars and restaurants are open in many parts of the country but FDA inspectors aren’t inspecting. It boggles the mind.

Let’s review. The FDA prevented private firms from offering SARS-Cov2 tests in the crucial early weeks of the pandemic, delayed the approval of vaccines, took weeks to arrange meetings to approve vaccines even as 1000s died daily, failed to approve the AstraZeneca vaccine, failed to quickly approve rapid antigen tests, and failed to perform inspections necessary to keep pharmaceutical supply lines open.

2021-04-14: the FDA is completely insane and is halting the distribution for the J&J vaccine due to very rare side effects. as before, there’s no consequences for acts of omission vs acts of commission. they’re much more worried about their “reputation” than actually saving lives, just like ethicists have been in this crisis. a disgrace.

As the Johnson & Johnson vaccine pauses in the United States, Philip Bump for The Washington Post offers a quick visualization that shows 100 vaccinations per second. A red one appears if there’s a side effect. But because the side effect is rare, currently at 1 in 1.1M, the red dot on the visualization likely never appears as you watch. The blue dots are potential lives saved if the J&J vaccine continues.

Citizens customers

One of the simplest and yet most profound changes is a shift away from calling people in the system “probationers” or “offenders” and instead referring to them, and treating them, as “clients” of city services. Helping to re-think the entire process of probation was a task force that included probation officers and clients from across the city

the description how the culture of endless waiting on plastic chairs was turned around is very inspiring, as is the directive to treat nyc citizens as customers, not as subjects.

Drugs Without the Hot Air

In the chapter “Is Ecstasy More Dangerous Than Horse Riding?” David Nutt again raises controversy. In the U.K., there are 5700 cases yearly of traumatic head injury from horseback riding accidents, 1 serious accident per 350 hours of riding. Dr. Nutt compares this rate to the yearly hospitalizations for ecstasy abuse and concludes that accidents from horseback riding and ecstasy abuse are on the same order of magnitude. Using this statistical comparison he wrote a “tongue-in-cheek” article for Lancet, the U.K. medical journal, calling addiction to horseback riding as “equasy:” equine addiction syndrome.

drugs are illegal because they are harmful, and they are harmful because they are illegal, except for alcohol and tobacco.

NYC Green Roofs

The benefits of a green roof, reduction of temperature, are very similar to that of the CoolRoofs, but add oxygen creation, water management and sound dampening.

2019-04-24:

rooftops on new buildings and those that go through extensive renovation on old buildings need to be covered in green roof infrastructure, solar panels or a combination of the 2.

Against Yoga mat donations

With the near unanimous support of its Congress, Honduras recently defined a new legal entity: la Región Especial de Desarrollo. A RED is an independent reform zone intended to offer jobs and safety to families who lack a good alternative; officials in the RED will be able to partner with foreign governments in critical areas such as policing, jurisprudence and transparency. By participating, Canada can lead an innovative approach to development assistance, an approach that tackles the primary roadblock to prosperity in the developing world: weak governance.

this is great: exhorting canada to export governance, not yoga mats, to help honduras. this could actually work (see singapore). there is a TED talk on charter cities too.

Tax Enforcement

how you can get a modicum of tax revenue in a cash-only society. take note, italy / greece.

China has crowdsourced tax enforcement, by potentially rewarding citizens with a cash reward for asking for all of their tax pre-payment receipts, and using them up by scratching off the prize areas. The cost of this massive force multiplier is vanishingly small, as all they are offering is the chance to win; I have only ever seen one winning ticket in the past couple of years, and it was for about 2 kuai. Still, it is a nice cultural touch to the end of a big meal, everyone sitting in a circle, scratching their fapiao to see if they won a prize for playing the part of a Chinese tax enforcement agent.

Regulations

eliminate 1 existing regulation for each new regulation

a compelling idea to keep the regulatory jungle trimmed.

Canada is now the first country in the world to require that for every new regulation introduced one of equivalent burden must be removed

a tiny step in the right direction.
2013-11-17: regulations are still treated like they will be around forever. an approach that takes their expected life span into account would do much good. perhaps for each new regulation an old one needs to go?